逗号后用词的问题Beethoven,the great musician,written nine symphonies in his life.请问这个句子中,逗号后应用分词结构,这里把written改为现在分词writing是否成立?

来源:学生作业帮助网 编辑:作业帮 时间:2024/05/05 14:30:24
逗号后用词的问题Beethoven,the great musician,written nine symphonies in his life.请问这个句子中,逗号后应用分词结构,这里把written改为现在分词writing是否成立?

逗号后用词的问题Beethoven,the great musician,written nine symphonies in his life.请问这个句子中,逗号后应用分词结构,这里把written改为现在分词writing是否成立?
逗号后用词的问题
Beethoven,the great musician,written nine symphonies in his life.
请问这个句子中,逗号后应用分词结构,这里把written改为现在分词writing是否成立?

逗号后用词的问题Beethoven,the great musician,written nine symphonies in his life.请问这个句子中,逗号后应用分词结构,这里把written改为现在分词writing是否成立?
逗号后往往是插入成分,多为同位语和补充性说明.此处很明显是半个句子,其主要结构应该是——


Beethoven + 缺省的谓语部分


可见,the great musician 和 written nine symphonies in his life 都是插入成分,前者是表明贝多芬身份的同位语,后者补充说明了他一生创作的交响乐.


但是,此处的 “写作” 的逻辑主语应该是 Beethoven,需要用现在分词 writing,等于 Beethoven wrote nine symphoniesin his life(贝多芬一生写了九部交响乐).如果用过去分词,就是成了Beethoven was written nine symphonies,意思变成 “贝多芬被写成了九部交响乐”.


因此,这里不是是否成立的问题,而是必须把 written  改为现在分词  writing.

楼主这个句子是哪来的?这个句子中的逗号中间应该是插入语,written应该改成过去形式的谓语动词,不应该用过去分词唉...